During my senior year at MIT, I remember comparing my job offers with a few of my friends. We discussed what base salaries and signing bonuses we were offered from various companies and some friends even shared with me how they planned to negotiate for more. Unfortunately, this type of discussion came to an abrupt end for me after college. Once I entered the workforce, discussing salary became taboo.
I bet a lot of women working in tech have no idea what they are making compared with their male counterparts (and I bet men don't know either). This data is not readily available at most tech companies. Employers have little incentive to disclose this data and probably even less incentive to analyze their data this way in the first place.
Here's some data that I did find:
Women make 77 cents on the dollar based on the 2008 US census and women earned less than men in all 20 industries and 25 occupation groups surveyed by the
Census Bureau in 2007. In tech, the situation may be slightly more equitable. According to a
2011 study by the US Department of Commerce, women in STEM fields (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) make 86 cents on the dollar.
I've seen at least one study that suggests this might be shifting, but it comes with a bunch of caveats. According to a
Time article from 2010, unmarried, childless women under 30 living in major cities were actually making more money than men in their peer group. However this same article said that the phenomenon doesn't apply when you look at peer groups in particular fields. For male-dominated fields, including tech, men are still out-earning women. From the article:
The holdout cities — those where the earnings of single, college-educated young women still lag men's — tended to be built around industries that are heavily male-dominated, such as software development or military-technology contracting. In other words, Silicon Valley could also be called Gender Gap Gully.
I found data more targeted to women in tech in a
2009 analysis run by Glassdoor, a site that collects salary data for many different jobs and companies. According to Glassdoor, "The analysis revealed that women engineers earn 96.7% of what men earn early in their careers (0-3 years experience), and earn 89.1% of what their male counterparts earn when both genders have more than 10 years experience." The gap widens dramatically when you look at just bonus pay.
So from what I have to go on, I hypothesize that there is a pay gap in Silicon Valley, but probably not one so insurmountable that we can't take steps to understand and correct it. Here's what I propose:
(1) Women need to get the data
The cold hard truth is that it does not benefit employers for their employees to know how much other employees earn. Having this information advantage means employers don't overspend when they don't have to in order to attract and retain talent. Not only that, it allows employers to overpay for talent on a one-off basis when necessary in order to compete with other employers. And women, who have been shown to negotiate less than men, may be getting the short end of the stick when it comes to keeping salary information private. It's time that women (and everyone for that matter) at least start considering how much they're earning compared with their peers. If you can't ask your peers directly, at least use the tools out there (I've checked out Glassdoor and Quora) to get a better sense of what you should be paid.
(2) Women need to negotiate
There are studies that show that women don't negotiate their salaries as much as men, or they're worse at negotiating, or that they don't value their contributions as highly as men do so they don't aim high enough if they do negotiate. So give negotiation a shot. Do as much research as you can in step (1) to find out what your peers are making and then estimate what you should make. Now add 25% to that because you're probably underestimating yourself.
(3) Women need to stop demoting themselves
This one deserves its own blog post so without going totally off topic, I'll just say that all too often women are sidelining themselves. I've seen this at all levels too. Sheryl Sandberg famously said "Don't leave before you leave", but I think that women need to do more than not leave, they need to double-down. I'm not discounting work-life balance and sleep and all that, but when you're doing your job, do it with all you got. Focus. Be present. Care.
So is there a wage gap in Silicon Valley? We need to keep asking until we're sure there's not.